Legendary Rare Tier List – One Rarity, 11 Units
Legendary Rare is a single community rarity label, not two separate lists for Legendary and Rare. This page covers all 11 names in that wiki group.
The damage rows are sorted by one placement’s max damage divided by SPA, excluding crits, passives, multi-target hits, cost, and buffs. Economy and support are described separately rather than forced into a damage ranking.


Damage-stat comparison
A damage-only comparison cannot measure support value or guarantee stage clears.
| Unit | Paper DPS | Reported limit |
|---|---|---|
| Alphys | 250 | 3 placements |
| Papyrus | 248.1 | 4 placements |
| Mettaton EX | 212.1 | 75 range |
| Toriel | 204 | 2 placements |
| Undyne | 199.6 | 3 placements |
The other six: economy and support
Temmie’s page describes cash each wave. Nice Cream Guy lists 6 gold per wave from the Gold stat. Muffet describes selling a donut for cash. Grillby reports a +5% gold bonus to units in range. These are community descriptions, not measured income rates.
Madjick reports 384 damage / 7.5 SPA = 51.2 paper DPS, two placements, and a Dazed passive that can make enemies walk backwards. KnightKnight reports 72 / 3 = 24 paper DPS and eight placements; its passive describes 1.5x damage for 30 seconds when an enemy attempts to stun it. These make control or conditional-damage candidates, not the top direct-damage rows. Boss immunity and current-client triggers have not been tested here.
Celestial Staff names Knight Knight (Celestial), but that item alone does not supply a complete evolved-unit comparison.
FAQ
Does rarity alone make a unit better?
No. Rarity is a classification, not proof of performance in a particular stage. Range, cost, effects, and your owned units matter.
How many Legendary Rare units are listed?
Eleven names in the checked community index, all covered in the damage or economy/support sections.
Why are gold units not ranked by paper DPS?
Cash generation and gold bonuses are not captured by damage divided by attack interval. Temmie, Nice Cream Guy, Muffet, and Grillby therefore receive role notes rather than a forced damage rank.
How we checked
Sources
Source links rechecked: 2026-11-03. Content evidence dates appear in the page notes; link availability does not certify gameplay. Community figures may change after an update.
- Units — community wiki
- Toriel — community wiki
- Papyrus — community wiki
- Grillby — community wiki
- Temmie — community wiki
- Undyne — community wiki
- Muffet — community wiki
- Alphys — community wiki
- Madjick — community wiki
- KnightKnight — community wiki
- Mettaton EX — community wiki
- Nice Cream Guy — community wiki
- Items — community wiki